There is a small debate which goes on all the while. This debate tries to understand which fiber type is better suited for weight loss. It seems that soluble fiber is better based on the article below. Learn why soluble fiber may be better for weight loss, though there are other benefits of insoluble fibers also.
Fiber is a well known nutrient, but not well understood. Put simply, fiber refers to carbohydrates that cannot be digested by humans. They are classified as either soluble or insoluble, depending on whether they dissolve in liquids.
Insoluble fibers function mostly as “bulking” agents and are not very interesting. However, soluble fiber can have powerful effects on health and metabolism.
Several studies show that soluble fiber can help you lose fat. But, this fiber must have certain properties.
Let me explain…
Fiber Feeds The Friendly Bacteria in The Gut
It’s estimated that around 100 trillion bacteria live in the human gut, primarily in the large intestine. These bacteria are known as the gut flora. Having bacteria in the gut may sound undesirable, but this is actually a good thing.
Different types (species) of bacteria play important roles in various aspects of health, including weight management, blood sugar control, immunity and even brain function.
Just like other organisms, bacteria need to eat well to stay healthy.
This is where fiber (mostly soluble) steps in. It passes through the digestive system mostly unchanged, eventually reaching the friendly bacteria in the intestine that end up digesting the fiber and turning it into usable energy.
Nourishing the friendly bacteria in the intestine is known as a prebiotic effect, and is believed to be very beneficial for health and body weight.
Another type of fiber called resistant starch behaves in a similar manner.
Bottom Line: Fiber does not get digested and tends to reach the large intestine relatively unchanged. There, certain soluble fibers can help feed the friendly bacteria that are absolutely essential for good health.
The Good Bacteria Help Fight Inflammation, a Key Driver of Obesity and Disease
Gut bacteria have long been known to have an effect on inflammatory pathways. They produce nutrients for the body, including short-chain fatty acids that feed the cells in the colon. This leads to reduced gut inflammation and improvements in related inflammatory disorders.
Just to clarify, acute (short-term) inflammation is beneficial as it helps the body fight foreign invaders and repair damaged cells. However, chronic (long-term) inflammation becomes a major problem when it is inappropriately deployed against the body’s own tissues.
We now know that chronic, low-level inflammation plays a major role in almost every chronic Western disease, including heart disease, Alzheimer’s and metabolic syndrome, to name a few.
There is also mounting evidence that inflammation is a strong driver of weight gain and obesity, possibly mediated via its effects on the hormone leptin.
Bottom Line: Inflammation is a strong driver of disease, including obesity. Fiber consumption has been linked to reduced inflammation.
Viscous Fiber May Reduce Your Appetite, Helping You Eat Less Without Trying
While I don’t believe that counting calories is necessary, it is a simple fact that we need to be in calorie deficit to lose weight.
That is, more calories (energy) need to be leaving the body than entering it.
Anything that reduces our appetite can make us take in fewer calories without having to think about it. Fiber is often believed to have this effect, making us feel more satiated so that we eat less.
However, according to the evidence, only a specific type of fiber does this.
A recent review of 44 studies found that while 39 percent of fiber treatments increased satiety, only 22% actually reduced food intake.
If we break it down further, it seems that the more viscous a fiber is, the better it is at reducing appetite and food intake.
Viscous soluble fibers such as pectins, β-glucans, psyllium, glucomannan and guar gum all thicken in water, forming a gel-like substance that “sits” in the gut.
This gel slows down the emptying of the stomach and increases the time it takes to digest and absorb nutrients. The end result is a prolonged feeling of fullness and a significantly reduced appetite.
There is some evidence that the weight loss effects of fiber target the belly fat specifically, which is the harmful fat in the abdominal cavity that is strongly associated with metabolic disease.
Bottom Line: Fibers with a high viscosity have been shown to increase satiety, reduce appetite and cause automatic weight loss. Fibers with low viscosity appear to have no influence.
Are Fiber Supplements Effective for Weight Loss?
Fiber supplements are typically made by isolating the fiber from plants.
While these isolated fibers may have some health benefits, the evidence for weight control is mixed and pretty unconvincing. A very large review study found that psyllium and guar gum (both soluble, viscous fibers) are ineffective as weight loss supplements.
One notable exception is glucomannan, a fiber extracted from the konjac root.
This is one of the most viscous dietary fibers known, and has been shown to cause modest weight loss when used as a supplement.
But in the real world, it’s the synergy of all the nutrients in foods that provides the most benefits, consuming isolated nutrients will never have the same effects.
For this reason, getting your fiber from whole plant foods is best.
Bottom Line: Fiber supplements are mostly ineffective for weight loss, with the exception of a powerful type of fiber called glucomannan. Getting your fiber from whole plant foods is the best and healthiest approach.
Rich Sources of Viscous Fiber
Viscous fibers are found exclusively in plant foods. Rich sources include beans (legumes), flax seeds, asparagus, brussels sprouts and oats, to name a few.
If you’re planning to switch to a high-fiber diet, remember to do it gradually to give your body time to adjust.
Abdominal discomfort, cramps and even diarrhea are common side effects if you ramp up your fiber intake too quickly.
Take Home Message
Adding more foods rich in fiber (especially viscous fiber) can be an effective way to lose weight.
But, same as with any other weight loss method, it won’t lead to long term results unless it comes with a lasting lifestyle change.
Also, let’s not forget that health is about way more than just weight. Eating plenty of fiber from real foods can have numerous other health benefits.